This Jalapeno Tuna Casserole is a healthy spin on the classic comforting casserole. Spaghetti squash is used in place of pasta and it’s packed with flakes of tuna and chopped jalapeno all smothered in a creamy sauce. You can make this casserole a day in advance and it freezes well too. This Whole30 Tuna Casserole is Paleo, Dairy Free, Grain Free, Gluten Free, Keto, and Specific Carbohydrate Diet Legal.

Truthfully I am a very latecomer to the world of tuna casserole. I mentally classified the dish in the same category as jell-o salad, spam and tv dinners, all retro food that did not need to make a comeback.

It wasn’t until university when my roommate made her family recipe for classic tuna noodle casserole that my view of the dish completely changed. It was comforting, satisfying and so delicious, I was in heaven!

The traditional dish is usually made with egg noodles, cans of cream of mushroom soup or condensed milk and heaps of cheese, so coming up with a dairy and grain free version was quite a challenge.

I ended up creating a delicious cashew based cream sauce that I can truly say tastes just like mushroom soup. To cut through the creaminess of the casserole I added in chopped jalapenos for a kick of heat, but if you want to keep it classic you can swap them for peas.

In place of noodles I used spaghetti squash, which works incredibly well in this casserole. The squash strands really do seem just like noodles, and they hold their shape and don’t become mushy once baked in the oven.

The trick to getting the best noodle like spaghetti squash is to cut the squash in half widthwise, rather then lengthwise. I have found that this method results in much longer strands of “spaghetti” and also requires a lot less cutting, which is a huge win if your knife skills are as terrible as mine.

Most tuna casseroles are topped with bread crumbs or cheddar potato chips, so in this recipe I made a brazil nut crumb that gets crunchy when baked. This Whole30 tuna casserole is so delicious on its own that truthfully the topping isn’t required, but if you want that added crunch then feel free to add it on.

Leftovers of this Whole30 Tuna Casserole will last for a few days in the fridge, or alternatively you can also freeze it. I tested out freezing a small portion of this dish and was impressed with the consistency of the “spaghetti” and creaminess of the sauce once thawed.

Here are a few more casserole recipes that you might enjoy:
- Spaghetti Bolognese Casserole
- Creamy Chicken, Broccoli & Bacon Casserole
- Beef & Cauliflower Rice Mexican Casserole
- Broccoli, Chicken & Rice Casserole
- Caramelized Onion, Butternut Squash & Turkey Breakfast Casserole
If you make this recipe let me know in the comment section below, I would love to hear what you think or take a photo and tag me (@everylastbite_) on Instagram, I love seeing your photos!
















Do you make your own almond milk or have you find a brand that doesn’t use any guns or sugars? As I understand they aren’t allowed on SCD?
Ugh auto correct…GUMS not guns 🙄
This was such a hit in my home. We’ve been on search for a clean tuna casserole for some time. Thank you for doing the leg work!
Made 100% like the recipe and it was perfect. I feel like this mushroom cashew sauce could be used for so much more.
So happy it was a hit!!
Is there anything I can use in place of the Brazilian nuts?
You could use walnuts or skip the topping altogether
Loved it! Will definitely make again
Awesome! SO happy to hear that Heidi!
I was skeptical about the nutritional yeast but this recipe was AWESOME. My family loved it and it’s the best Tuna Casserole I’ve had. And it’s healthy. I didn’t need it low carb but I did need it dairy free. I added peas to this recipe and doubled the tuna.
Woah what a comment! I am so happy you enjoyed it! For anyone trying to avoid dairy, nutritional yeast is a great addition to give a slight cheesy flavour 😄
This was so awesome. I used almonds instead of cashews. Will definitely be making this again!! Thank you!!
I’m so happy that it worked with almonds!!
Delicious! My husband and I truly enjoyed this! Thanks for sharing!
Awesome! I’m so happy you enjoyed it!
AMAZING! I typically don’t eat canned tuna and this dish is soooo good! Thanks for sharing and never disappointing!
Yeess! So happy to hear you enjoyed it!
Is there something else I can use instead of Cashews?
Blanched almonds or macadamia nuts would also work well
i made this last night and OMG! WHAT a fantastic recipe. As always, you never disappoint, Carmen! I enjoyed mine with a splash of hot sauce Thanks 🙂
Yea!! Your comment totally made my day! SO happy that you enjoyed it!